Why Better Customer Service Starts with Better Employee Experience
- Peak Support
Article overview: Customer service employees can’t do their best work when the job itself keeps making good service difficult. They need the right information within reach, enough people to share the workload, managers and coworkers they can count on, and the freedom to make sound decisions without second-guessing every move. When that support is missing, the quality of service can suffer along with the employee experience. A customer service strategy that takes both seriously gives employees a stronger foundation to do their jobs well and customers a better chance of getting the service they expect.
Good Service Needs Something to Work With
There’s a point where “the agent should have handled that better” stops being a useful explanation. Maybe they should have. But what happens when a customer service agent isn’t allowed to make the obvious call? Or when the answer they need is buried in an old document? That same agent might even know a process isn’t working but have learned that raising the issue won’t change much. Eventually, you have to look past the individual conversation and ask what kind of job the company has made customer service into.
Matthew Ruby, US Program & Community Engagement Associate at GiveDirectly, spoke about that same idea during Peak Support’s Rising CX Leaders Awards. At GiveDirectly, “recipients first” is the number one value, with “team next” right behind it. Both matter because how employees experience their work can affect the experience they give customers. As Matthew put it, “One thing that companies can do to improve the overall quality of the customer experience is improve the experience for their employees as well.” He also made the point that employees need support from each other to be at their best when helping customers.
There’s a lot packed into that idea. Companies ask customer service employees to be patient, knowledgeable, resourceful, empathetic, and confident with customers. It’s a lot easier to be those things when the job isn’t fighting you at every turn. Employee engagement and customer experience meet right there, in whether someone has what they need to do good work on an ordinary Tuesday. That makes the employee experience part of a customer service strategy, whether a company treats it that way or not. Better service is easier to deliver when employees aren’t spending their energy working around the job itself.
Enough People, Not Enough Time
A customer service team can have the expected number of employees working and still be stretched thin. Forecasts are built around expected volume and how long conversations are likely to take, but customer issues don’t always cooperate with those averages. When more conversations need extra time, employees have less room to give it without falling behind. That’s when being fully staffed and having enough capacity stop meaning the same thing.
That’s why the staffing number can look right while the day-to-day reality says otherwise. Some customer issues consistently take longer to resolve, and customer demand isn’t evenly distributed throughout the day or week. Not every working hour is available for customer conversations either, since employees also need time for training and other responsibilities. A staffing plan that accounts for all of that gives employees more room to handle the work that takes longer than expected.
How customer service employees respond to that pressure can tell you whether the staffing plan is working. If they’re regularly rushing customer conversations or putting off other responsibilities just to stay on top of incoming inquiries, hitting the staffing target isn’t telling you the whole story. A customer service strategy should take those signs seriously. The number of employees scheduled matters, but so does whether that number gives them enough time to provide the service expected of them.
Plenty of Information, No Clear Answer
A company can document just about everything its customer service employees need to know and still make their jobs unnecessarily difficult. Having the information somewhere isn’t enough. Employees need to be able to figure out which answer applies to the customer in front of them, especially when two documents seem to say slightly different things or the guidance doesn’t quite fit the situation they’re dealing with. Your customer service strategy should help employees turn all that information into a clear answer, because giving everyone access to a knowledge base is only part of the job.
Jhania Perkins, Customer Experience Lead at Bedloft, brought up the importance of “being knowledgeable about your processes, being knowledgeable about your products” during Peak Support’s Rising CX Leaders Awards. That responsibility can’t sit entirely with the employee. Companies have to make sure employees can make sense of the product and process information they’re given. If the written guidance leaves room for interpretation, the answer shouldn’t depend on which coworker happens to be available or which document an employee finds first.
That’s where customer service knowledge management becomes more useful than simply collecting information. Pay attention to where employees disagree about the right answer. Those disagreements can show you why employees are coming away with different answers even when they have the same information. That’s worth fixing because better documentation shouldn’t just help employees find an answer faster. It should help two employees looking at the same customer situation reach the same answer with confidence.
Problems Raised, Still No Fix
Agents won’t keep raising the same problems forever. If they’ve mentioned something several times and the problem still hasn’t been addressed, they’ll eventually work around it and carry on. Then managers hear less about it even though nothing’s really changed. And when a customer service agent goes quiet, that doesn’t always mean the problem’s solved or that everything’s fine.
What happens after an agent speaks up matters just as much as asking for feedback in the first place. If different agents keep bringing up the same customer problem, that’s no longer just something to discuss in coaching. Find out what keeps causing it and bring in the department that has the power to change it. Then bring the answer back to the agents who raised it. Not every concern will lead to a change, but people should know what was considered, what was decided, and why.
Pay attention when agents keep passing the same makeshift solutions around the team. That’s a sign they’ve figured out how to keep helping customers while the actual problem remains unresolved. Helping each other through it is valuable, but once that becomes the team’s regular response, managers need to know what agents are trying to solve on their own and why it keeps happening. Otherwise, agents can become remarkably good at dealing with a problem that shouldn’t be theirs to manage in the first place. That’s an important link between employee engagement and customer experience: making the job better for agents includes fixing the problems they’ve quietly learned to manage before customers keep running into them too.
Too Many Approvals, Not Enough Authority
Some agents spend a surprising amount of time waiting for managers to approve routine decisions. When those decisions keep getting the same answer, the approval starts to feel less like a safeguard and more like an extra stop for everyone involved. Agents have to pause what they’re doing, managers get pulled into decisions that don’t need much judgment, and customers wait longer for an answer that was fairly predictable from the start.
That pattern is worth paying attention to. If managers are making the same call day after day because the criteria are already clear, agents should be able to handle more of those decisions themselves. That takes unnecessary approval work off managers and gives agents more room to help customers without stopping for permission. A customer service strategy still needs boundaries around higher-risk decisions, but agents should know what they can decide themselves and what still needs approval.
And when they do need approval, agents shouldn’t have to message several managers before reaching the right manager. The same goes for escalations that keep getting redirected or sent back because something is missing. If that keeps happening, make it clearer where different issues go and what agents need to send with them. Getting an escalation where it needs to go shouldn’t become another reason the customer has to wait.
Good Service Shouldn’t Require So Much Work
Customer service employees already have a demanding job. Helping customers takes patience, judgment, and care, and the way the job is set up can either support that or make it more difficult. When employees have what they need, they have more time and energy for the part that matters most: helping the customer. That connection between employee engagement and customer experience plays out in the day-to-day work. A customer service strategy should make it easier for employees to do that work well.
That’s the kind of customer service team we want to build at Peak Support. We take the time to understand what each client wants for their customers and what those customers care about, then give agents the context to serve them well. When something keeps making good service more difficult, agents and managers can raise it so we can work with the client on what needs to change. We don’t want agents simply following a process. We want them to know the work well enough to make good decisions for the customer.
If your customer service team needs more support to give customers the service you expect, let’s talk about how Peak Support can help.